At this table you have:

-DM (OP)

-Player 1 (DM’s friend, inexperienced)

-Player 2 (P1’s gf, experienced)

-Player 3 (P1 and P2’s bf - it’s a polycule, experienced)

-Player 4 (P3’s sister)

Heck it doesn’t even have to be a “deal”. I’m sure at least a few entities (Archfey, maybe) would grant magic powers just to see what happens. Sort of like the Outsider in Dishonored.

Shepard-Commander?

blue-robed figure lunges at you with a knife

Since when does “not being comfortable role-playing” make you a bad player?

The consequence was I broke my lock picks. So not only did I not get the info and had to pay the wager, I had to buy new lock picks.

Fortunately, this lock was in a test-bench type setup, and the locksmith was able to eject the broken pieces of my pride lock picks.

That die 100% ended up in dice jail