Greetings friendly psychopaths!

This is maybe not the best fit for the comm but it is entirely due to rimworld, as that’s my benchmark. Please let me know if this should be elsewhere; I just figured this would be my best bet for a good and relevant answer.

I need a new computer. The laptop I’ve been playing on hard crashes and needs reboot constantly when gaming (worst with rimworld, where I freeze every 0.5-3 hrs, but oxygen not included and dysmantle both suffer as well and that’s like half of what I want to play rn). And for whatever reason the other computer I have it installed on won’t boot it anymore (I don’t have the new expansion, so that’s not it). It just crashes right before fully loading. Probably the mod loadout but nearly all of these ran on the laptop, so idk what the deal is. Anyway that tower is my Plex server so it was never meant to run games. I got it cuz it was rly rly cheap.

So, I’m not made of money or skill… quite the opposite. I need this as cheap as possible. If I had any confidence in myself I’d replace the failed components in my 2016 gaming tower but that probably just needs to be gutted at this point (mobo failure) and idk how to build into the corpse, tbh. I guess I can learn but idk if I have the mental energy for that rn. So that’s why I’m here, asking!

Regardless if I buy a tower, repair and upgrade the one I have, or build into the corpse, I’d like to know the minimum hardware requirements to run this specific game decently. Doesn’t even have to be that top-of-line sort of good! Just not constantly crashing my entire computer would be great! Currently about 3-4 years in, at best, I end up with so many entries in my spreadsheet, and so many tps (even with all the performance mods), that my pawns need rim rails just to play at a halfway acceptable speed, and 1x and 3x are exactly the same speed. That’s without even fucking with raids and stuff; just basic base building is too much. Granted they are opulent bases, and I have numerous recreation and hospitality mods, but that’s hardly the point. I’ve never run more than 150 mods at a time afaik and I understand some people manage twice that without this problem. I’m also fastidious with mod order and grouping, in the hopes it’ll improve performance.

So I’m looking for numbers. I intend to go with 32gb ram and hdd/ssd doesn’t really matter cuz I can replace that whenever. I have a dramatically overly large (for what it was running) psu, 800w I believe, so I have wiggle room even if I reuse that. I also have an old water cooling system I can throw in for funsies. I assume those don’t obsolete.

Is there a minimum CPU? What about a good mid-range GPU (I understand this to be overall the more costly portion)? Anything else I’m missing?

It’s not a bleeding edge game, and I don’t tend to play bleeding edge games, so I don’t need it to do more than this. If it can run rimworld well, it’ll do anything else I need equally well (I’ll just have to accept I’m not getting a vr for it)

  • ButteryMonkey@piefed.socialOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    Ā·
    27 days ago

    Thanks that’s very helpful!

    I looked up parts on pc part picker that were compatible with a gigabyte b650m which meets the am5 standard and was the first cheap one I found (old pc was also gigabyte mobo, and I was happy with it overall). For the things I know I need to replace (cpu, gpu, mobo, ram, and a new cooling system just in case) in the sort of cheapest I could find category, came to $720 with a 3060 and 2x16 ddr5. I can swing that. My max budget was $1,200 or so, but I’d have been upset with myself the whole time for it. That’s a sizeable chuck of my money. Still, I do this stuff instead of going out and spending, so it’s worth investing in.

    That’s ofc looking at new parts. Used would probably be better priced, but as a rough estimate sort of thing that’s workable.

    • AliasVortex@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      Ā·
      27 days ago

      Unless you’re running a small form factor case, I might recommend stepping up to a full sized ATX mobo if you can squeeze it into the budget. As long as your CPU is supported it’s hard to go wrong, but I generally prefer the extra headroom of full sized boards; mostly for situations where I might need to toss in an extra drive or something, plus they’re usually a bit less cramped which makes them easier to work on. (Personally, I’m not a huge fan of Gigabyte. I haven’t sworn them off, but I find their software to be kinda clunky and annoying. Plus, I have two different machines with Gigabyte bios’ that seem to think ā€œwake on LANā€ means wake up randomly in the middle of the night, just because).

      In general, RimWorld is pretty CPU bound (especially if you’re running a moderate or heavy mod list (modders don’t always write the most optimized code, myself included)), so a 3060 is probably overkill (assuming you don’t play anything else that might need it). From a RimWorld performance standpoint you’d get much more bang for your buck by cheaping out on the GPU and putting the money towards your CPU (1.6 brought in a bunch of multi threading and performance improvements, but generally speaking, a higher CPU clock speed means the game takes less time to do the computational work per tick. For the). Alternatively, if we’re talking as cheaply as possible, you might be able to get away with no GPU and using the CPU embedded graphics, it won’t be driving any AAA titles on 4k displays at crazy high refresh rates, but for RimWorld and the other games you’ve mentioned it should be plenty. Plus, the GPU is technically something you could come back and add later.

      Also, it might be worth keeping an eye on the buildapcsales subreddit (there’s technically a Lemmy comm, but I don’t think it’s official affiliated and it looks pretty dead), especially if you’re thinking new hardware. If you live near a Microcenter, they’re known for doing CPU + mobo deals that stack with other promos. I’ve also had good luck with Best Buy’s price match (they won’t match Microcenter’s bundle, but if it’s a single item on sale it’s usually fair game).

      If it helps, this is probably the list I’d be working off of, if I were buying today: pcpartpicker. It totals up to $645, which keeps it under your budget, but gives headroom to find a cheap GPU on the second hand market or a monitor or two if needed. The 7900X should easily handle the game (and pretty much anything else you throw at it), at $300+ it’s not cheap, but (as long as it’s not thermal throttling) I’ll do more for your TPS than a similarly priced GPU (7600X could probably be subbed in as a more affordable option (saves you $150). The boost ceiling is slightly lower, but still gets you most of the same performance at a much lower power draw and price tag).

      Funny enough, it’s not all that dissimilar from my current build, build primary as a video transcoding rig (also a CPU bound endeavor) to feed my Plex server (and handle late game RimWorld, but I will admit to having been too busy lately to put that to the test).

      • ButteryMonkey@piefed.socialOP
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        Ā·
        27 days ago

        I got the biggest case available when I bought this one, specifically so I could replace stuff down the line. I just didn’t bank on that being such a… big task. :)

        Thanks for this info! I appreciate it! I’m sort of at a loss when it comes to hardware or how this shit even works, so including the build for me was super helpful!

        Since I still have a GPU from a few years ago (certainly a bargain model but a standalone card nonetheless) I’m gunna try your suggestions, and just get a different video card if needed. Even a $200-300 gpu would only bring me back up to the 6-700 range so.

        I stepped down to the 7600, but with everything and thermal paste, $460 for new, which is very doable (I couldn’t find the stuff used but that’s mostly because I couldn’t tell if the thing was the same as what I was looking for…). It’s all an upgrade from where I’m at now, so that works for me. And I still have the 256gb ssd installed in that old beast so I… feel like that’s probably everything that I can’t just reuse from the existing situation (like the bays and stuff). I also swapped over to this because it’s available tomorrow where the other wasn’t until mid September, and it was actually less expensive, despite apparently being better in nearly every way… hopefully that’s not a mistake.

        That’s far far far better than I was planning. I’m really glad I came on here and asked, you lot have been super helpful.

        • AliasVortex@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          Ā·
          26 days ago

          I had a whole mini guide on PC building and then accidentally clicked cancel after checking my formatting and lost it, oh well…

          Oh, an old GPU is perfect! One of my builds rocked a 750ti well past it’s prime, and it only got replaced because one of the HDMI ports gave up the ghost. Plus, Black Friday isn’t all that far off, so there’s a slim chance you might be able to find something more on sale once you decide if it’s needed.

          Yeah, AM5 is still somewhat new, so it’s not as common on the second hand market. Plus, I get 'ya, the second hand market can be tricky for some stuff if you’re not super read up on all the tech/ acronyms and cross referencing every part (nobody wants to buy a bunch of things and go to put it together only to realize it doesn’t work together).

          Another personal preference, but I might recommend a second SDD if you can swing it (I tend to favor the WD black and Samsung pro lines, but realistically anything is probably fine. I believe this list is the one the buildapcsales folks reference. Speaking of, here’s the current sales). Moving to a new system can be a bit chaotic and it always feels bad to lose data (because you forgot that Thunderbird stores your emails in appdata or that mods you were working on were in program files and not your user folder). Plus, windows can get weird if you just re-home the drive into a new board. I usually try for a clean install if I can, just to remove all the old drivers and do some spring cleaning. If you do end up with a spare drive kicking around, something like this is by no means necessary, but a handy way to turn it into a giant flash drive for backups/ PC moves.

          Oh nice! That’s the same mobo I’ve got. My only real complaint is that the MSI utility for RGB will only run under the local administrator account, which isn’t that big a deal, otherwise it’s been pretty solid.

          I’m happy to have helped! If you have any other questions, feel free to ask!