The Federal Communications Commission announced Monday that it is slapping the leading U.S. cellular providers with nearly $200 million in fines for selling
$91 million in fines for T-Mobile + $12 million for Sprint. T-mobile made $8.32 billion of net income in 2023. The fines represent 1.21% of their net income.
$57 million for AT&T. AT&T made $14.2 billion in the same time period. 0.42% of their net income in fines.
$48 million for Verizon. They made $11.6 billion. 0.41%.
In comparison, let’s take the median working class guy making median income, rounded up a couple thousands to a nice $40k/year. We’re comparing net income, so after income taxes, deductions, living expenses, let’s be generous, guy is great at budgeting, lives frugally, say he’s still left with $20k/year. The worst fine is roughly equivalent to the average American having to pay a $242 fine. Not even taking into account that in this situation, the guy likely made tons of profit from the transaction in the first place.
The difference is that $242 hurts when you only have $20k per year. These fines don’t hurt these companies at all. They likely had the money set aside already, in case they were fined.
Oh, wasn’t saying it didn’t hurt, you don’t have to remember me of my years making $12k/year as a student on top of student loans and debt to survive lol. But it shouldn’t even be equivalent to how much a $242 fine can hurt. A $242 fine is equivalent to what, a speeding ticket? The crime committed is orders of magnitude worse, yet the penalty doesn’t nearly scale up. Corporations are getting off easy for the scale of the crimes committed, time and time again.
$91 million in fines for T-Mobile + $12 million for Sprint. T-mobile made $8.32 billion of net income in 2023. The fines represent 1.21% of their net income.
$57 million for AT&T. AT&T made $14.2 billion in the same time period. 0.42% of their net income in fines.
$48 million for Verizon. They made $11.6 billion. 0.41%.
In comparison, let’s take the median working class guy making median income, rounded up a couple thousands to a nice $40k/year. We’re comparing net income, so after income taxes, deductions, living expenses, let’s be generous, guy is great at budgeting, lives frugally, say he’s still left with $20k/year. The worst fine is roughly equivalent to the average American having to pay a $242 fine. Not even taking into account that in this situation, the guy likely made tons of profit from the transaction in the first place.
The fines for these things need to be a hard percentage.
revoke their corporate charter for 5 years. You wanna fucking be people? Then do your time for your criminal behavior.
Better yet, throw the asshole who mandated the activity into prison.
Now you are talking. It is insane that you can simply buy a license to commit crimes, but that’s what incorporation is nowadays.
The difference is that $242 hurts when you only have $20k per year. These fines don’t hurt these companies at all. They likely had the money set aside already, in case they were fined.
Oh, wasn’t saying it didn’t hurt, you don’t have to remember me of my years making $12k/year as a student on top of student loans and debt to survive lol. But it shouldn’t even be equivalent to how much a $242 fine can hurt. A $242 fine is equivalent to what, a speeding ticket? The crime committed is orders of magnitude worse, yet the penalty doesn’t nearly scale up. Corporations are getting off easy for the scale of the crimes committed, time and time again.